IMPORTANT
SITE UPDATE:

Visit the relaunched
Fish & Fly at fishandfly.com

 

Click Here to Visit!

Ask The Panel Archive

Q. I fish on a small stillwater and noticed that a trout I caught had been eating bloodworms. More

Q. Could you tell me which is the best nymph to use during the months April, May and June on stillwaters?
More

Q.
I have never fished a trout competition before. Could you briefly tell me any thing I should know More

Q. I hear of people discussing tippet length. Is there a general rule of thumb to lengths or is it to stop spooking fish More

Q. Could someone please explain to me why traditional 'Loch style' fishing with wet flies is recommended by most experts when fishing Scottish lochs More

Q. How important is the red spot near the thorax in the original Czech nymphs? More

Q. I have recently taken up fly fishing and would like help with a problem I am getting with my casting. More

Q. I've converted to fly fishing from coarse and sea recently (about two months ago) and I'm having trouble getting distance on my cast More

Q. I want to replace the top eye on my fly rod, but don't know how to remove it without damaging the rod.
More

> See more previously answered questions...



I fish on a small stillwater and noticed that a trout I caught had been eating bloodworms. Could you tell me how I would fish this fly and also any info on how to fish daddy longlegs would be helpful. Dave Cook

The blood worm is a chironomid larva and the red colouration is haemoglobin which absorbs what oyxgen there is in the mud. Chironomids are also known as buzzers. The larvae turn into pupae underwater and then wriggle their way to the surface to hatch. Any imitation should be bright red and can be fished very deep when there is no hatch. A team of flies fished on a floating line and allowed to drift with the breeze can be very effective as can a steady draw, to imitate a pupa making its way to the surface to hatch. Try fishing at different depths to establish the depth at which the fish are feeding.

The daddy longlegs or crane fly is a terrestrial or land-based insect. They get blown on to the water by the wind and tend to get trapped in the surface film so they cannot move much, if at all. Although early autumn is the most popular time for them, they do appear at other times. Use a good bouyant imitation and cast it out with the wind behind you. Leave it to drift and pay out line as it goes. And all being well, it will make a trout a tasty last snack Terry Lawton

Could you tell me which is the best nymph to use during the months April, May and June on stillwaters?

This question arrived just as I was reviewing Henry Lowe's book, Reservoir trout, A bank angler's guide. I am sure that he won't mind me quoting from this very useful book. Choice of fly does depend to a great extent on the weather conditions and whether or not there are any flies hatching. Also certain patterns of nymph can be fished to represent different nymphs by fishing them at different depths and speeds of retrieve. A change of size of the same pattern can often do the trick. The flies that Lowe lists include claret, red, ginger, green and olive buzzer nymphs, pheasant tail and Cove's pheasant tail, amber nymph, stick fly, gold ribbed hare's ear, green thorax pheasant tail, pond olive, damsel nymph, green and orange hot-spot pheasant tail, flashback and Montana nymphs. A selection of these chosen to give a good range of colours and styles, in a range of sizes, should serve you well. You may want to add some with gold or copper bead heads. Terry Lawton

I will be fishing a competition (organised through work) in June at Brenig, North Wales. I have never fished a trout competition before. Could you briefly tell me any thing I should know - i.e. Do I kill all the fish I catch? If I'm in a boat with a stranger is there any etiquette that I need to observe? Can I fish a team of flies etc etc? I am fairly new to fly fishing and any advice would be received very gratefully. Michael Cross

I am sure that the organisers of the competition will brief you on the rules governing the competition. This will include whether fish are to be caught, measured and returned or caught, killed and weighed at the end of the day. How to handle and fish from a boat in safety and without upsetting your companion needs a whole article. This is something that we will look into. In the meantime, I would suggest that you get hold a book such as "Reservoir Fishing with Tom Saville" which has a very good chapter on boat fishing basics and one on boat fishing tactics. Make sure that you and your partner know what each of you are doing, for example if you want to cast in a different direction, and try to agree what each of you expects from the other. If you are fishing with an experienced partner, I am sure that help will be forthcoming. Terry Lawton

I've been fishing for five years now and only having poor to moderate success. I hear of people discussing tippet length. Is there a general rule of thumb to lengths or is it to stop spooking fish? Harry Mellor

Although the tippet needs to be of a size suitable to the size of fly - bigger fly thicker tippet, smaller fly finer tippet - there is no similar rule of thumb regarding length. Too short a tippet is likely to frighten fish as the thicker part of the leader, and the fly line, will be that much closer to the fish and therefore more visible. A tippet of about 750mm (30 inches) is a good length to start with. You may want to try something longer for fussy fish in clear water, or reduce the length if casting into a strong wind. As you change fly you reduce the length of tippet. When you have only 450mm (18 inches) left, tie-on a new, longer tippet. In your question you say that you have had only moderate success. Can I suggest that you look at some of the articles in the Techniques section of this site? I hope they will be helpful and improve your success. Terry Lawton

Could someone please explain to me why traditional 'Loch style' fishing with wet flies is recommended by most experts when fishing Scottish lochs - even lochs which have a rich aquatic fly life. I live near Brenig in N. Wales and the methods employed there are more akin to other large waters in England and Wales, eg. Buzzers & other imiative patterns.

Josh

I think this is a case of established local fashions coming before experimentation. The methods used at Brennig i.e. imitative patterns and buzzers will catch trout on Scottish lochs just as I can see no reason why traditional loch style patterns should not catch fish at Brenig.

The key point when fishing large waters be they lochs, lakes, reservoirs is flexibility - adjusting your fly and line selection according to the prevailing conditions. On big exposed waters if there is a big wave, larger (Size 10) loch style patterns like the Kate McLaren, Zulu, Invicta, Soldier Palmer will usually work. In calmer conditions nymphs, small dry fly and buzzers can be applied - be adaptable and you should get there. Lesley Crawford


My question is very simple. How important is the red spot near the thorax in the original Czech nymphs? António Rodrigues, Portugal

One of our contacts in the Czech Republic, Ales Martinek, says that in his opinion it is important because fish can see it easily. He says that he uses more colours than red - orange and pink. He says the best way is stay in one pool and fish for up to one hour with nymphs with a coloured spot (often referred to in the UK as a hot spot) and one hour without. Last year his best Czech nymph was made from orange rabbit with black thorax or with a goldhead.

Jan Siman confirms that the red spot attracts fish, like the red tail of the Red Tag fly. He says that they use different attractors, for example, pearl angel hair mixed with squirrel dubbing for the thorax. Terry Lawton

I have recently taken up fly fishing and would like help with a problem I am getting with my casting. I quite often get knots in the tippet (I believe they are called "wind knots".) I would appreciate any views you may have. Cliff Proud

The knots you refer to are not caused by wind although the wind may sometimes be involved indirectly in producing these annoying little knots because of what it can do to your cast. The knots are caused primarily by casting faults and most commonly by what is called a tailing loop.

A tailing loop occurs when your fly catches your fly line on either the forward or backward cast. A tailing loop causes the fly to pass below the level of the fly line instead of over, or above, it. The result is either an unsightly pile of spaghetti at the end of the cast or, at best, a knot or knots in your leader. Neither is good for catching fish due to poor presentation and a severely weakended leader due to the "wind" knots.

A few tips on avoiding tailing loops:
1. Try to smooth out your casting style. Tailing loops are produced as a result of the mis-application of power in the cast.
2. Try to use less power in your casting: let the rod do the work.
3. Try to cast with a little less line. You may be overloading your rod by using too much line. And remember if using a weight forward line, you must only use the head of the line to cast and the thinner running line to shoot.
4. This is probably the most important tip: get some professional instruction from a member of the Game Angling Instructors' Association who holds the Advanced Game Angling Instructors' Qualification, APGAI. Look in Fly Fishing & Fly Tying magazine for a list of members advertising or e-mail me, via this site with your location, and I will give you details of your closest instructor. Vic Knight APGAI

I've converted to fly fishing from coarse and sea recently (about two months ago) and I'm having trouble getting distance on my cast. I use a weight forward line and my cast is OK but would like to get further. I don't try to power out the last cast as before. Any advice would be welcome. Dave Cook

The first point to make is that you do not have to cast into the next county to catch fish. On stillwaters and rivers you can and will catch many fish within five or ten yards (or metres if you prefer). If you manage to cast a full line - and some backing too! - you will find it much harder to detect a gentle take, harder to set the hook and you will have a job getting all the line back onto your reel as you try to play any fish that you do manage to hook and get it with reach of your net without tangling the line round your feet.

Please spend time perfecting your cast over short and medium distances and looking to see what is happening and where the fish are. When you are happy that your casting and presentation is consistently good, then you can think about increasing casting distance. To achieve distance you need to learn the double haul. Double hauling increases line speed which gives you the extra distance. We hope to publish an article on the double haul cast in the near future. Terry Lawton

I want to replace the top eye on my fly rod, but don't know how to remove it without damaging the rod. Also, what would be the best top eye to buy, a "hay fork" eye or "fuji" type? I curently have a hay fork eye, which is very soft, and requires some straightening after a period of use. Douglas

Tip tops, or the top ring on a rod, can be fixed either with hot melt glue or epoxy. Either glue can be softened by dipping the end of the rod into boiling water and then twisting the ring free, holding the ring with a cloth as it will be hot. If you replace the ring with hot melt glue, you run the risk of the glue softening if you leave the rod in a car near the widscreen on a hot sunny day. I would suggest that you use five minute epoxy or Araldite Rapid. As regards the choice of ring, you should use a Fuji-type tip top if you have Fuji or lined rings on the rod. If you have snake rings, then a hay fork would be a better match. You can get rings from Hopkins & Holloway. Ask for a catalogue and the name of your local dealer: sales@hopkinsholloway.demon.co.uk Terry Lawton

> See more previously answered questions...